City Island · The Bronx, New York

Coastal Italian.
The Bronx

Honest Italian cooking rooted in the sea — from artisan pizzas and fresh clam pies to grilled octopus, house-made pasta, and a wine list built for discovery.

Signature artisan pizza at City Island Pizza Co., Bronx NY
★★★★★

“What a wonderful find! All food is fresh—the restaurant has no freezer. Meats are sourced from local butchers and bread is made with imported flour. Service was friendly and attentive. This place is a gem. From now on, this is my go-to on City Island.”

OpenTable Guest · OpenTable
★★★★★

“City Islanders do not realize they have a 5-star dining establishment right in their backyard. Every course was amazing and the drink selection was top notch. The CIPC burger with its special blend of meats is outstanding.”

OpenTable Guest · OpenTable
★★★★★

“The owner Rene creates a warm, meaningful experience for every guest. Incredible meatballs and rice balls—the flavors are fresh and the service is genuinely attentive. The Sunday supper special is absolutely worth the trip.”

Verified Diner · Google
★★★★★

“Brought friends for their first time and they loved it! Great pizza, eggplant, and scarp. Service was always terrific. The gluten-free options are remarkable—you’d never know the difference.”

OpenTable Guest · OpenTable
★★★★★

“The lobster roll is prepared with butter and herbs—not drenched in mayo. Zeppoles and the tiramisu are must-tries. With options to dine inside or outside, this has become a must-visit spot every time we’re on City Island.”

Google Reviewer · Google
★★★★★

“First time delivery here on the island—yummy, so good! We had the pepperoni pizza and it was awesome. Warm atmosphere, attentive staff, and thoughtful food-and-wine pairings. This place is a hidden gem.”

Google Reviewer · Google

Where City Island
Meets the Table

What began as a fresh addition to City Island has grown into a community mainstay. Created by Rene Matos — whose career spans more than two decades across Marriott and the world of wine and spirits — this restaurant is the sum of every experience, relationship, and standard he carried along the way.

That philosophy shows in the kitchen. We cook the way we eat: with quality ingredients sourced as close to home as possible, respect for Italian tradition, and an eye toward what’s in season. From our fresh clam pie — a nod to the island’s seafaring roots — to the Sunday-supper pappardelle bolognese, every dish here has a point of view. This is coastal Italian through a Bronx lens.

Est. City Island, The Bronx  ·  273 City Island Ave

Best of the Bronx 2025

Three-time winner — voted by the Bronx community

Celebrate
With Us

Whether you're planning an intimate dinner, a milestone celebration, or a corporate gathering, we bring the same care to private events that we bring to every table in our dining room.

Group Dining

Private and semi-private dining for parties of all sizes, with custom menus crafted for your occasion.

Inquire About Group Dining
Catering

Pre-order for pickup or delivery throughout City Island and greater New York. Pizza spreads, passed appetizers, Italian feasts.

Request a Catering Quote
Gift Cards

Give the gift of a great meal. Digital gift cards available for any occasion.

Purchase a Gift Card

Find Us on
City Island

MondayClosed
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday5:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Thursday5:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Friday5:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Saturday3:00 pm – 10:00 pm
Sunday3:00 pm – 8:00 pm
273 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464